2023 Minute Media - All Rights Reserved. The epic culmination of an 11-year film saga is upon us with Avengers: Endgame, and thats no overstatement. Its entirely possible that once a sacrifice has been made, one can no longer take back what was lost. So both Gamora and Black Widow died for the Soul Stone, Gamora directly by the actions of Thanos and Black Widow sacrificing herself. Why can Gamora come back but not Black Widow? She then joined the Avengers, often fighting alongside them until her demise in Avengers: Endgame. You might say it has a certain wisdom In order to take the Stone, you must lose that which you love. 18 biggest questions we have after watching - gamesradar Why does Acts not mention the deaths of Peter and Paul? thanostrich 4 yr. ago But do you believe that one? Both Gamora (Zoe Saldana) and Black Widow (Scarlett Johansson) died on Vormir to unlock the Soul Stone, but the Gamora still alive by the close of Avengers: Endgame is a past version displaced from 2014. It only takes a minute to sign up. So, Thanos is completely removed from the universe after the Ironman gauntlet snap right? 8 years . Q: Can you get the soul your sacrificed for the Soul Stone back when you return it? Early in Endgame, when the Avengers visit Thanos at The Garden, its revealed that Thanos used the Infinity Stones to destroy the Stones. Directed by Joe and Anthony Russo, Endgame has already surpassed one billion dollars at the box office in a matter of days. The tribute soul for the Soul Stone will forever be sealed in that place, therefore Black Widow is gone forever. But, again, theres another issue at play: Captain America returned all of the Infinity Stones to their respective times and when it comes to the Soul Stone, which has its own negotiating ritual, that means that 2018-Gamora and Black Widow should still be alive after Endgame rolled credits. NEW YORK, NEW YORK NOVEMBER 02: Scarlett Johansson attends an event hosted by David Yurman in support of Lower Eastside Girls Club at David Yurman 57th St on November 02, 2022 in New York City. Generating points along line with specifying the origin of point generation in QGIS. Even if you have returned it to its original location, you wouldn . Our version of Gamora is dead. For the most part . (we don't know; it's not discussed.). For more information, please read our Legal Disclaimer. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. What Happened to Gamora in Avengers: Endgame? - IGN According to Insider, Red Skull, the protector of the Soul Stone, made it clear that whoever gives their life for the stone cannot in any way be brought back. She later joined the secret agency S.H.I.E.L.D under the leadership of Nick Fury. Black Widow and Hawkeye went back to 2014 to acquire the Soul Stone. I think the words used by Red Skull are that the Soul Stone requires an "everlasting sacrifice", Could they not have grabbed a copy from earlier that day? Many fans had been wondering with the complexities of the Marvel Cinematic Universe timelines, why the Avengers couldnt have brought back Black Widow aka Natasha Romanoff. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. When Gamora went off that cliff, the Gamora from that time period died. Boolean algebra of the lattice of subspaces of a vector space. The notion that any of them is correct is subjective. 'Avengers' Scarlett Johansson Says Black Widow Definitely - Insider We have past Gamora from before the events of Guardian's of the Galaxy as she remained in the present timeline after the second Endgame snap. Basically, what we're saying is that even though Vision and Loki and Gamora died in Infinity War, events in Endgame have ramifications for the status of their actual deaths. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. She had also warned that failure to the aforementioned would result in a number of alternate realities getting opened up and therefore, even Natashas return would prove to alter the timelines. They'd only need to fill her in a day and it clearly works because it did for Gamora. Folder's list view has different sized fonts in different folders, the Allied commanders were appalled to learn that 300 glider troops had drowned at sea, Can corresponding author withdraw a paper after it has accepted without permission/acceptance of first author, Horizontal and vertical centering in xltabular, Passing negative parameters to a wolframscript. thank you ! What do hollow blue circles with a dot mean on the World Map? For now, you can still see her in Avengers: Endgame. She does however have a solo film coming out, but thats a prequel. Cassie Lang is also the older version during this same scene. The Marvel Cinematic Universe has brought fans plenty of superhero action over the years that its been on screen. In other words, theres no way of getting 2018-Gamora back. Why refined oil is cheaper than cold press oil. After Avengers: Endgame is there any movie worth seeing? It also depends, heavily, on who was. Why Can't Black Widow Have A Child? - Explained Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. This is due to slot in betweenCaptain America: Civil WarandInfinity War, as well as dipping into Nats dark past as a Russian assassin. Avengers: Endgame was a very emotional movie for a number of reasons, but one of the more obvious reasons involves death. Okay. Tragically, however, this was not to be, as it was explained that though Hulk attempted to bring her back when he reversed Thanos snap, it didnt work for some reason. Many fans have been asking why Gamora could come back - but Black Widow could not. Copyright 2023 ComicBook.com. Why can't the Avengers go back in time and bring an earlier self of the deceased? In Avengers: Infinity War, when Thanos killed Gamora, trading her soul for the Soul Stone, Gamoras soul was sent to what many fans theorized was Soul World. So both Gamora and Black Widow died for the Soul Stone, Gamora directly by the actions of Thanos and Black Widow sacrificing herself. Why did DOS-based Windows require HIMEM.SYS to boot? Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts. Natasha Romanoff, aka Black Widow, sacrificed herself for the Soul Stone that defeated Thanos. Photo via Marvel Studios. Which Avengers: Endgame Deaths Are Permanent? | Den of Geek They have already caused Thanos (and friends) and Nebula to be removed from that timeline. Black Widow is said to be resistant to any diseases or aging, which makes her almost indestructible. The returnee should get a soul back. Still, it would have been a treat to see two of the MCU's most dangerous women working . And they never tried to do it when they were in the land of vibranium? Or as **fanlore.org** calls it [Watsonian, not a Doylist point of view](http://fanlore.org/wiki/Watsonian_vs._Doylist). Since the Soul Stone requires a spiritual trade, a soul for a soul, we argued that if you return the Stone, then those conditions work both ways. Gamora will totally be in the 3rd Guardians of the Galaxy, but we won't get her back. Yet Gamora, who was sacrificed for the Soul Stone came back, even though it was through time travel. Yes we do, but not the same Gamora. New blog post from our CEO Prashanth: Community is the future of AI, Improving the copy in the close modal and post notices - 2023 edition. So should she stay dead? Gamora died by Thanos hand in Infinity War after he sacrificed her to get the Soul Stone, which he used to wipe away half of humanity. Natasha Romanoff is a fictional character created by the late Stan Lee. After all, the Gamora who died on Vormir is still very much deceased, and the version who currently exists in the MCUs main timeline is effectively a different person. Here is where things get tricky. Does a password policy with a restriction of repeated characters increase security? Then again, theres another issue to take into account: the Avengers traveled back in time and created alternate realities. Zoey Deutch, Glen Powell reunite with 'Set It Up' team for new Netflixrom-com, Avengers: Endgame Why the Defenders and X-Men were not used, Avengers: Endgame In defense of Steve Rogers, Captain America's future teased by the events of Avengers: Endgame. This is confirmed by a recent interview of the directors: Q: Can you get the soul your sacrificed for the Soul Stone back when you return it? 3. Corrected: Assuming the second Endgame (Stark) snap didn't send, New blog post from our CEO Prashanth: Community is the future of AI, Improving the copy in the close modal and post notices - 2023 edition. What's to stop them going back to the day before Black Widow died and pulling her into the present timeline? And since Cap only knows of Black Widows sacrifice, then its likely the case that Black Widow was the one brought back to life after Avengers: Endgame came to an end. Her stats were above Widow's {she performed a 30ft leap clean} and the fodder she fought was generally better armed, Gamora is faster in combat; her H2H feats are actually more impressive. why is gamora back alive but widow isn't able to come back? someone Be sure to tell us all of your thoughts in the comments section down below. In fact, its not really returning the stone, more like put it back properly. After Black Widow sacrificed herself for the Soul Stone, Hawkeye then traveled back to the main reality, where Hulk was then able to use all of the Stones to bring back the dusted. 'Avengers: Endgame directors just explained some of the movies biggest mysteries, BGR, April 30th, 2019. For when you die, it will be . [MCU/Endgame] If a past version of Gamora can be brought to the present day, why can't Black Widow be restored in the same way? But if that is the case, then theres no reason at all to return the Soul Stone. Add to that Hulks last words in Endgame, before he sent Cap back in time, where he said that he really,really tried to get Black Widow back, then perhaps theres something to this theory. 3, whenever that arrives. Was Thanos really committed or just a hypocrite? You know, like you do.. Scarlett Johansson has played Natasha Romanoff for ten years. rev2023.5.1.43405. "As you do," quipped co-writer Stephen McFeely. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Why don't we use the 7805 for car phone chargers? The tribute soul for the Soul Stone will forever be sealed in that place, therefore Black Widow is gone forever. Avengers: Endgame Writers Explain Why Gamora Returned But Black Widow If this happens to be true, then we are in for one crazy of a Black Widow movie. Ubuntu won't accept my choice of password. Natashas death paves the way for MCUs phase 4 in which fans will get to see a new set of characters, including a new Black Widow, Yelena Belova, played by Florence Pugh. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Of course, by that same logic, there remains every possibility that a Black Widow from an alternate reality might show up somewhere down the line, but at the very least, it sounds like the Natasha Romanoff we currently know is indeed gone forever. So there you have it. Hulk was only able to bring back everyone who was turned to dust. Why didn't he come back? A: No, the process is irreversible. Fans were shocked when Black Widow sacrificed herself so Hawkeye could claim the Soul Stone on Vormir halfway through Avengers: Endgame. dusted along with all the Thanos army by the Avengers' use of the Guantlet. So shes still alive, she traveled in the time machine to the present. It seems a sacrificial death made to claim the Soul Stone cannot be undone, even by the combined power of all six Infinity Stones. Boolean algebra of the lattice of subspaces of a vector space? 3: Who is Adam Warlock. So, as it appears, in order to return the Soul Stone to its dominion, a soul for a soul still stands. All picks and predictions are suggestions only. You can use the Infinity Stones from alternate realities (or different points in time) to undo what the other Stones already did in another timeline. [MCU/Endgame] If a past version of Gamora can be brought to - Reddit Look out for that in theaters on May 1st. This is confirmed by a recent interview of the directors: Q: Can you get the soul your sacrificed for the Soul Stone back when you return it? Simple deform modifier is deforming my object. To recap, we argued that Black Widow and 2018-Gamoras souls are within Soul World and that Soul World works akin to the Quantum Realm, in which theres only one and where time and space work differently. Gamora vs Black Widow (Movie Versions) - Battles - Comic Vine The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? The process for earning the Soul Stone is irreversible. As per Insider, protector of the Soul Stone, Red Skull had initially clarified that sacrificing oneself for the stone means that the person can never be brought back. Well the leaker that said that insinuated that there are 2 copies of the infinity stones and steve destroys the one Black Widow died to get, which is why Gamora doesnt. It can be assumed that bringing back Natasha could alter the timeline, thus opening up Pandoras box in the process. There no coming back from that. You know, like you do.". Why didn't an Asgardian go to Earth sooner? 3. Can Natasha have kids in the comics? 3 is about; although it's unclear whether Saldana's contract has her in it: a couple years ago, the whole cast was planned to be doing three volumes at least, but that might change. It's a little complicated to understand, but here goes nothing: . Both 2018 Gamora and 2023 Black Widow's deaths are irreversible, part of an everlasting exchange preventing their resurrection. While speaking on the commentary track for the film (available on Digital HD now), Joe Russo said that the key to understanding this is in paying close attention to what Red Skull tells them. This time, the conversation revolves around Black Widows controversial sacrifice in Endgame, a death that is an otherwise exact replication of Gamoras own fridged demise, as some fans have put it. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. And in an interview with Variety, co-writer Christopher Markus explained how one heroine could come back but not the other. However, if Gamora was brought back in Avengers: Endgame, fans were curious to know why Natasha couldnt have been brought back either. Can I use the spell Immovable Object to create a castle which floats above the clouds? Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. In the comics, Black Widow and Gamora don't have much of a connection, save for the occasional crossover. Could a subterranean river or aquifer generate enough continuous momentum to power a waterwheel for the purpose of producing electricity? Returning the stone simply wouldn't bring the dead one back. The original Gamora, who starred in both Guardians of the Galaxy and Vol. In Endgame, a past version of Gamora was brought into the present timeline. See the interviews above that clearly and definitely state it doesn't work like that - Nat's dead, period. Just saw Endgame. Question about Gamora and Vision spoilers 8. As for Natasha Romanoff, were pretty sure she isnt coming back in anything set chronologically afterEndgame. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Many of you who watched Avengers: Endgame already knew this, but for those of you who didnt, you now know. Scan this QR code to download the app now. But in current Timeline Gamora is dead. All rights reserved. There appears to be no negative ramifications except there being a Gamora again. In this time setting, 2018-Gamora wasnt yet sacrificed for the Stone, obviously. Assuming he was, as the film wants us to believe, that means he went to Vormir (a.k.a. Retrieving a still-living Black Widow from an earlier timeline "would've been a weirdly selfish decision," Markus said. Natasha on the other hand does not exist after the point in time from where the Soul stone was retrieved so there is no copy to get. In Endgame, a past version of Gamora was brought into the present timeline. Why do Gamora came back to life but Black Widow couldn't in Avengers 'Endgame': Why the Avengers Couldn't Bring Natasha Back from Another