They shall only be contradicted by science. It doesnt remember much. So, why then should there be a major concern using these vaccines to fight Covid-19? Dr. Vanden Bossche has also taken to social media to air his concerns, and his message has been enthusiastically embraced by antivaxxers: Lets just say this. Over the last several months, Ive listed a number of examples of this phenomenon of antivaxxers recycling hoary tropes to apply them to COVID-19 vaccines; for example, claims that vaccines kill, cause infertility, cancer, autoimmune disorders, and Alzheimers disease, and are loaded with toxins, among several others, such as the claim that they alter your DNA. Geert Vanden Bossche - PhD, DVM - Independent | LinkedIn In their lengthy medical op-ed on LifeSite News, Dr. Paul Alexander and Dr. Geert Vanden Bossche warn the public health decision makers that the mass vaccination program that uses "imperfect non . However, this type of prophylactic vaccines [sic] are completely inappropriate, and even highly dangerous, when used in mass vaccination campaigns during a viral pandemic. Are vaccines destined for a similar fate? When you read Dr. Bossches open letter, you should pick up on the Galileo gambit, which is when you infer that because Galileo was laughed at but ultimately correct, your laughable idea must also be correct. Up to this point, at its core and leaving aside minor variations, Dr. Vanden Bossches argument about COVID-19 vaccines and COVID-19 is pretty close to exactly the same argument that Wakefield fallaciously made about MMR and measles. Basically, Dr. Vanden Bossches open letter is a mess that directly channels Andrew Wakefield. Bret speaks with Dr. Geert Vanden Bossche in Bath, England, together for the COVID Better Way Conference 2022. As the innate immune system cannot remember the pathogens it encountered (innate immunity has no so-called immunological memory), we can only continue to rely on it provided we keep it trained well enough. Hence, it also offers unprecedented advantages in terms of safety, convenience and cost-effectiveness. PDF Former Gates Vaccine Scientist Predicts Mass Genocide After all, if a human vaccine lets deadlier versions of a disease flourish, that is all the more reason to be protected from those deadly strains. Geert Vanden Bossche says mass vaccination might boost a surge of new covid variants. Amazon has encountered an error. After three years of hearing all kinds of explanations and mixed messaging, this book finally brings clarity to what's been going on. His LinkedIn profile lists several impressive positions, including Head of the Vaccine Development Office for the German Centre for Infection Research (for seven months, August 2017-February 2018); Chief Innovation & Scientific Officer for Univac, where he claimed to be an inventor of a new vaccine technology based on natural killer (NK) cells (2014-2016); and the managing director of VARECO, claiming to be a consultant about vaccine development (2012-present). Specifically, scientists have long been pointing out that, the more we let COVID-19 circulate, the more likely virus variants that can escape the immune response to the vaccine (and/or to natural infection) are to emerge, and they use this argument as a rationale for vaccinating as many people as possible as fast as possible, in order to slow that circulation of the virus to as low a rate as possible, thus reducing the opportunities for strains resistant to the vaccine and strains able to re-infect previously infected people to emerge. In my new book, The inescapable immune escape pandemic, I am sharing my insights and perspectives on how the Covid-19 pandemic continues to evolve. While there is no doubt that current vaccines will become less effective over time due to genetic drift, this is not something that vaccine science is unaware of or unprepared for. The author's unique approach and reliance on basic scientific principles make this a valuable addition to the literature on the subject. Edward Nirenberg, a science blogger who addressed Dr. Bossches claims in great detail, points to Mareks disease. The more extensively the later age group will be vaccinated and hence, protected, the more the virus is forced to . [Editors note: Scott Gavura had circumstances pop up that prevented him from producing a post for today. This is an absurdly counterproductive solution if Vanden Bossche were truly concerned about variants. Ive attached the slides of the keynote that I held yesterday at the Vaccine Summit in Ohio ( ^Why should current Covid-19 vaccines not be used for mass vaccination during a pandemic? Reviewed in Germany on February 22, 2023, Learn more how customers reviews work on Amazon. Please try again. Kindle Unlimited: Magazine subscriptions included. These public commentators, often bedazzled with advanced degrees, have painted themselves as brave mavericks escaping from the mainstream herd to denounce the cataclysmic consequences of public health measures. Sterilizing Immunity: How The Mass Vaccination Strategy Got It Wrong In fact, I basically said the same thing in 2019 when writing about Andrew Wakefields invocation of the same argument regarding the MMR vaccine and measles variants. Basically, its a race against evolution to get as many people as possible vaccinated before the virus can evolve resistance to the vaccine, and were fortunate that, contrary to Bossches claim, SARs-CoV-2 does not mutate very fast for an RNA virus. Geert Vanden Bossche received his DVM from the University of Ghent, Belgium, and his PhD degree in Virology from the University of Hohenheim, Germany. Where do we plant our next step? One of the cell types of the innate immune system is a natural killer cell, and Dr. Bossche claims to be developing a natural killer cell vaccine. Dr. Bossche, however, seems to be a big fan of the innate immune system and he worries that all of these COVID-19 vaccines and public health measures are getting in the way of our innate immune system fighting off the coronavirus. Full content visible, double tap to read brief content. Buscar Amazon.es. Clearly, variability in the spike glycoprotein can affect the efficiency of antibody neutralisation. However, as we age, we will increasingly face situations where our innate immunity (often called the first line of immune defense) is not strong enough to halt the pathogen at the portal of entry (mostly mucosal barriers like respiratory or intestinal epithelia). voiceforscienceandsolidarity.org. Because of their fast (NK cells) and universally protective effect, Univac vaccines are uniquely suited to prevent pathogenic agents from escaping host immune responses as of an early stage of infection or immune-mediated disease. The classic example of a leaky vaccine is actually the one for Mareks disease, caused by a herpesvirus that infects chicken and causes lymphoma among other illnesses. This problem will be exacerbated, he claims, because people who have been vaccinated (and/or social distancing and staying inside during the pandemic) will be less capable of fighting off those strains than someone who has not been vaccinated. If they are exposed to the virus during this time, their immune response may be too weak to effectively fight it off. See | 69 comments on LinkedIn A recent review article suggests that immune escape by variants of SARS-CoV-2 is a possibility, but one that hasnt been definitively observed or demonstrated yet: So is there cause for concern? Moreover, as Nirenberg points out, there is an increasing body of evidence that the COVID-19 vaccine is not leaky. GENEVA/NEW YORK, 15 July 2020 - The World Health Organization and UNICEF warned today of an alarming decline in the number of children receiving life-saving vaccines around the world. Hola Elige tu direccin Todos los departamentos. Vanden Bossche's argument, however, basically boils down to the idea that current COVID-19 vaccines, in conjunction with other preventive measures, are making the pandemic exponentially worse by breeding infectious variants. The virus is now able to escape immunity (so-called: immune escape). Racing against the clock, I am completing my scientfic [sic] manuscript, the publication of which is, unfortunately, likely to come too late given the ever increasing threat from rapidly spreading, highly infectious variants. The Inescapable Immune Escape Pandemic by DVM, Geert Vanden Bossche The Inescapable Immune Escape Pandemic: Vanden Bossche MD PhD, Geert I believe I speak for many scientists when I say: show us the evidence. Bossche claims that the same thing will happen with the coronavirus. The present extremely critical situation forces me to spread this emergency call. He reminds me of another doctor who spread misinformation about COVID-19 vaccination based on an unbending principle of immunology to justify his concerns, without any clinical or epidemiological evidence to support it. Geert Vanden Bossche, PhD Geert Vanden Bossche, PhD, DVM, is a vaccine research expert. This book provides a thought-provoking analysis of the complex interactions between the virus and the host immune system that underlie the evolution of the COVID-19 pandemic. It's important that this book is out there. Ultimately, most vaccines are based on a recombinant spike protein sequence. Lets compare Dr. Vanden Bossches letter to what Wakefield wrote back in 2019. As I suspected, Dr. Vanden Bossche is selling something. Its been accompanied by a video interview posted towhere else?antivaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.s Childrens Health Defense website. One benefit of several current COVID-19 vaccines, most notably the mRNA vaccines, is that they can be easily modified to induce the development of antibodies programmed specifically to deal with whatever new variants crop up. As any chicken farmer knows (or any veterinarian like Dr. Vanden Bossche should know), vaccinating against Mareks disease has population health benefits in that it prevents mass death due to the disease, even if the vaccine can allow more virulent strains to evolve. Geert Vanden Bossche on Twitter: "Continued mass vaccination will only In my new book, The inescapable immune escape pandemic, I am sharing my insights and perspectives on how the Covid-19 pandemic continues to evolve. His LinkedIn profile lists several jobs in upper management positions, including a three-year stint as the senior program officer for vaccine discovery at the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. Vanden Bossche has created a scientific-sounding argument that vaccination will encourage the production of COVID-19 variants that our immune systems will be unprepared to fight. The Inescapable Immune Escape Pandemic (ebook), Geert Vanden Bossche And so am I. I searched PubMed for what I expected to be an extensive publication record on vaccines and foundeight publications, the most recent of which was from 1994 and none of which have anything to do with vaccines. Potentially leaky vaccine but stellar disease reduction. The way to avoid this purported calamity, Vanden Bossche asserts, is for scientists to pay more attention to his own invention a "universal vaccine" that uses the body's innate immune system to kill SARS-CoV-2. But if you have a full and overpowering army at your command, the invaders wont stick around for long. This piece is an interview conducted by Rob Verkerk, Ph.D., with Geert Vanden Bossche, Ph.D. An example of a leaky vaccine is the vaccine against Mareks disease, highly contagious and deadly viral disease of chicken that is a major problem in the poultry industry, and Dr. Vanden Bossche relies on this precedent, as Nirenberg explains: For a moment though, lets entertain the notion that the vaccines are leaky. FALSE: Geert Vanden Bossche says mass vaccination might boost - Poynter Author of 'From Midnight to Moonlight' - a book about cats and angels. The second benefit to Vanden Bossche's claim is that it places his purported invention as the miracle solution to the COVID-19 pandemic. David H. Gorski, MD, PhD, FACS is a surgical oncologist at the Barbara Ann Karmanos Cancer Institute specializing in breast cancer surgery, where he also serves as the American College of Surgeons Committee on Cancer Liaison Physician as well as an Associate Professor of Surgery and member of the faculty of the Graduate Program in Cancer Biology at Wayne State University. This material may not be reproduced without permission. This book provides a thought-provoking analysis of the complex interactions between the virus and the host immune system that underlie the evolution of the COVID-19 pandemic. Unfortunately, Dr. Vanden Bossches open letter has gone viral and is being spread on antivaccine social media everywhere as slam dunk evidence that COVID-19 vaccines will cause a global catastrophe by selecting for the evolution of highly transmissible and deadly variants of COVID-19 that will escape immunity due to vaccines. For vaccines, resistance equates to strains of the microbe, the virus, or the bacteria that can elude the imperfect immunity created by the vaccine. geertvandenbossche . The bottom-line is that I dont see how mass vaccination campaigns would not lead to a disastrous aggravation of the Covid-19 . If you are a potential patient and found this page through a Google search, please check out Dr. Gorski's biographical information, disclaimers regarding his writings, and notice to patients here. Medical Op-Ed: Mass Vaccination Creates "Excellent Breeding Grounds As those have stronger affinity for the pathogen (e.g., virus) and can reach high concentrations, they can quite easily outcompete our natural Abs for binding to the pathogen/virus. Update your device or payment method, cancel individual pre-orders or your subscription at. (Indeed, thus far, it appears that this is the case.) However, Bigtree, Coleman and others dont point out any of the red flags. Vaccine Expert Vanden Bossch Believes Mass Vaccination Is Likely To Turn The Relatively Harmless Virus Into A Bioweapon (drug, retired) . But even if the COVID-19 vaccines were leaky, meaning they still allowed some vaccinated people to transmit the virus to others, there is evidence that they could still efficiently contain the spread of the disease. To follow Dr . Now, lets compare the passage above to what Andrew Wakefield wrote about MMR and vaccines: Antibiotic use has selected out multiply resistant, more dangerous, and more pathogenic strains of bacteria. The author delves into the impact of mass vaccination on individual and global health, and explains how powerful organizations, institutions, and industries lacking an understanding of this complex environment have turned a natural viral pandemic into one of disastrous immune escape. Its not an instantaneous solution, as massive vaccination campaigns require manufacturing and deployment at scale, but its a fix we know well and have implemented in the past. It is precisely this type of highly specific, high affinity Abs that current Covid-19 vaccines are inducing. Dr. Bossche asserts that vaccines are like antibiotics in that, when they are both overused and imperfect, they allow germs to mutate in dangerous ways. You should pick up on the tactic too often used by anti-vaccination promoters: I am all but an antivaxxer. You should subsequently pick up on the types of people who grab this manifesto and endorse it for their audience, people like Robert F. Kennedy, Jr and Del Bigtree, known figureheads of the modern anti-vaccination movement. Its at this point, though, that Dr. Vanden Bossche throws in a twist specific to COVID-19 in which he argues that undertaking a mass vaccination campaign during a pandemic is dangerous. As a creative thinker, innovator, entrepreneur and visionary, Geert has been invited to speak at multiple international congresses. Vanden Bossche has achieved some public attention for publiciz-ing an open letter to the World Health Orga-nization opposing vaccinations against SARS-CoV-2; his letter has been seized upon by advocates against vaccination as it seems to #254 - Dr Geert Vanden Bossche: Predictions on the Evolution of Covid Originally Posted by MissTerri Geert Vanden Bosch didn't use Del Bigtree or JFK jr. to spread his message. Therefore he has zero credibility when it comes to advising the public or anyone else about how to avoid negative effects of mass vaccination. You know what? As I go through Dr. Vanden Bossches open letter, Ill point out the similarities, while also noting differences when they occur. Sufficient scientific evidence has been brought to the table. He subsequently worked with the Global alliance for Vaccines and Immunization (GaVI) in Geneva as senior ebola Program Manager and with the German center for Infection Research in Cologne as Head of the Vaccine Development Office. Actually, its not just eerily similar, its almost exactly the same, namely that immunity from vaccines is an evolutionary selective pressure just like the evolutionary selective pressure from antibiotics to which the organism can become resistant.. After his career in Academia, Geert joined several vaccine companies (GSK Biologicals, Novartis Vaccines, Solvay Biologicals) to serve various roles in vaccine R&D as well as in late vaccine development. Dr. Geert Vanden Bossche: Covid Mass Vaccination Triggering New In any case, for someone who is so not antivaccine, Dr. Vanden Bossche sure is good at providing ammunition to the antivaccine movement. The Inescapable Immune Escape Pandemic by Geert Vanden Bossche DVM PhD Actually, its not just eerily similar, its almost exactly the same, namely that immunity from vaccines is an evolutionary selective pressure just like the evolutionary selective pressure from antibiotics to which the organism can become resistant. Waiting for Vanden Bossche's "universal vaccine" is no way to win such a race. It makes things a lot clearer, even if I cannot understand everything. Your membership is the foundation of our sustainability and resilience. This is not all that impressive, given that Snopes could only identify two patent applications in Vanden Bossche's name both for "immunologic formulations" and both of these patents, records indicate, had their "applications terminated before publication.". COVID-19 mass vaccination will select for more virulent variants of the virus that causes COVID-19, which will escape vaccine-induced immunity and cause more severe disease. Fact Check: Mass Vaccination Amid The COVID-19 Pandemic Does NOT Create Its a rationale for developing reformulated booster vaccines that cover variants not well covered by the currently-used COVID-19 vaccines. This is a bad argument. COVID-19 vaccines are critical for controlling the pandemic; vaccines Again, this is an argument antivaxxers have made dating back at least to the pertussis vaccine. It won't be easy for everyone to to hear their mistakes. WHO and UNICEF warn of a decline in vaccinations during COVID-19 First of all, note how Dr. Vanden Bossche is conflating vaccine-induced immunity with natural immunity. Several variations of the originally isolated strain have emerged since the start of the pandemic, and some of these variants are more infectious, contagious, or possibly deadly. Thankfully, there is a vaccine against it, but over time, newer and more virulent strains of the virus have been detected, and this made scientists think it was because the vaccine was leaky, that it did not allow the chicken to mount a good enough immune response. To all authorities, scientists and experts around the world, to whom this concerns: the entire world population. Its a common argument among antivaxxers that the reason were seeing more cases of pertussis in people who have been vaccinated against it is because pertussis is either evolving resistance, or because it is shifting to a different strain not covered by the vaccine. This is a very confused argument. Sure, we dont yet have a firm grasp of how much the vaccine decreases transmission, but there is good emerging evidence that it does significantly decrease transmission. Another important counterpoint to Dr. Bossches claim is that we can simply reformulate our vaccines to match new variants of concern.